{"edition":"archive-ca","kind":"past-measure","id":"ca-1996-prop-218","record":{"id":"ca-1996-prop-218","area":"ca","number":"218","date":"1996-11-05","title":{"en":"Voter Approval for Local Government Taxes. Limitations on Fees, Assessments, and Charges. Initiative Constitutional Amendment."},"summary":{"en":"Required a majority of local voters to approve increases in general taxes, restated that two-thirds must approve special taxes, and limited local assessments, fees and charges."},"result":"passed","links":[{"questionId":"believe.tax-threshold","direction":null,"reason":{"en":"The official summary says Proposition 218 \"Requires majority of voters approve increases in general taxes and reiterates that two-thirds must approve special tax.\""},"sourceUrl":"https://repository.uclawsf.edu/ca_ballot_props/1138","sourcedBy":"sourcer-questions-fix"}],"sourceUrl":"https://repository.uclawsf.edu/ca_ballot_props/1138","sourceTitle":{"en":"California Ballot Pamphlet, General Election, November 5, 1996: Proposition 218, Official Title and Summary (UC Law SF California Ballot Propositions database)"},"sourceKind":"voter-guide","sourceDate":"1996-11-05","archiveUrl":"https://web.archive.org/web/20261002012909/https://repository.uclawsf.edu/ca_ballot_props/1138/","sourcedBy":"sourcer-questions-archive"},"fingerprint":"c31624038303893a823d3f0659b3ed1b3b7b4b8a88528f388156e0acf3f18840","proof":{"id":"ca-1996-prop-218","edition":"archive-ca","fingerprint":"c31624038303893a823d3f0659b3ed1b3b7b4b8a88528f388156e0acf3f18840","entry":{"seq":1,"prev":null,"edition":"archive-ca","publishedAt":"2026-10-03T05:05:39.350Z","records":[{"id":"ca-1978-prop-13","kind":"content","fingerprint":"829f0dc9343060c10a2074c8a63d3b27e01752b75658c9eaae52445818e24b32","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-1988-prop-73","kind":"content","fingerprint":"180ace379cb45d9134823ae6f60171cc062b4cdad932157350d91bab3b41aab2","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-1996-prop-218","kind":"content","fingerprint":"c31624038303893a823d3f0659b3ed1b3b7b4b8a88528f388156e0acf3f18840","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-2012-prop-30","kind":"content","fingerprint":"c583e061f90fabcfe974a7c970965c9fba6bc444e264ab90ee6d89b55e111870","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-2014-prop-2","kind":"content","fingerprint":"f9b0b7e66dd599d3e5f121a4f27434673f7bd0433d88a4544b5fe59bb399e113","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-2016-prop-55","kind":"content","fingerprint":"1d4036b072b09fc81debb2b49d403353d3e8cd2034d69a10c740bb4a574cf7d0","supersedes":null}],"merkleRoot":"d12f8e2dfa106ff2bd5e2cef627574928ca528a328b6e00558c6b3e6b793bc70","serviceSig":{"keyId":"service:a3f979541aee7826","sig":"0gB5+tRSy6Ed8X8sI0KHmYKgpTdiaswDHDuDB78jjFcurXhaRxBCIh9QLrHFWuwSqq2TiFKPadWDUpkkPdYBBg=="},"ownerSig":{"keyId":"SHA256:h82SrxLU1wYr+jpy4Vl9/9iQlAO+HQX1umVBdhy/Ss0","sshsig":"-----BEGIN SSH SIGNATURE-----\nU1NIU0lHAAAAAQAAAGgAAAATZWNkc2Etc2hhMi1uaXN0cDI1NgAAAAhuaXN0cDI1NgAAAE\nEEoxp1EZZ9rp5AYfMO9hQLs04GmJM0haaJgOQhAuCHlPkycB3FgiORcXWBtEUua5jLg16r\npgFNQZQ7R7CMCmON2QAAABJpZGVvbG9neS1pbnRlZ3JpdHkAAAAAAAAABnNoYTUxMgAAAG\nUAAAATZWNkc2Etc2hhMi1uaXN0cDI1NgAAAEoAAAAhAJIB9+tLQ1N2+QmyAr14b8hQsSYE\njY868CkEhuw5WJotAAAAIQC7QK5Sous22qq370XdMOmKHxAB0P4i8wdTlbLhM+2uhQ==\n-----END SSH SIGNATURE-----\n"},"receipts":[{"witness":"rfc3161","status":"ok","ref":"integrity/receipts/1/rfc3161.tsr"},{"witness":"opentimestamps","status":"pending","ref":"integrity/receipts/1/opentimestamps.ots"}]},"merkleProof":{"index":3,"path":["829f0dc9343060c10a2074c8a63d3b27e01752b75658c9eaae52445818e24b32","4fc8fe17edab0da9cc65dd848d3b45b8d85c85d897ae588437cb4832b8c36933","51704f2357e6fd005526cbb44f4071b708f6e36f76b7d07b6b104819be218652"]},"versions":[{"seq":1,"publishedAt":"2026-10-03T05:05:39.350Z","fingerprint":"c31624038303893a823d3f0659b3ed1b3b7b4b8a88528f388156e0acf3f18840","supersedes":null}]},"judgments":[{"id":"ca-1996-prop-218@believe.tax-threshold:link-direction","record":{"id":"ca-1996-prop-218@believe.tax-threshold:link-direction","subjectId":"ca-1996-prop-218@believe.tax-threshold","kind":"link-direction","tier":"result","call":"believe.tax-threshold:none","rationale":{"en":"The official summary says Proposition 218 \"Requires majority of voters approve increases in general taxes and reiterates that two-thirds must approve special tax.\""},"alternatives":[],"author":"sourcer-questions-fix","panelDecisionId":null,"supersedes":null},"fingerprint":"ced98cd2f96dfeee6e01e4294ea20c9b513e6d89d848bf61572d1adfc75cf0a1","proof":{"id":"ca-1996-prop-218@believe.tax-threshold:link-direction","edition":"archive-ca","fingerprint":"ced98cd2f96dfeee6e01e4294ea20c9b513e6d89d848bf61572d1adfc75cf0a1","entry":{"seq":5,"prev":"f4857ee09528ae2d1dc0188bc789c235345fe76bce0099ac318629c02a68cb9c","edition":"archive-ca","publishedAt":"2026-10-03T05:31:23.125Z","records":[{"id":"ca-1978-prop-13@believe.tax-threshold:link-direction","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"36f1e4064669b907f18798db971f46718a942c40e29bb42b3a9762ee41e09311","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-1988-prop-73@believe.campaign-money:link-direction","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"21b548fc0fb8125a93261ed325eefcd9d4ae03d3b9e09336105a8fb97721ec95","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-1996-prop-218@believe.tax-threshold:link-direction","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"ced98cd2f96dfeee6e01e4294ea20c9b513e6d89d848bf61572d1adfc75cf0a1","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-2012-prop-30@believe.tax-share:link-direction","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"617c510a065e8f5065e5c2d4fb03b933d25d925e33db705d77ee5a92a248b841","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-2014-prop-2@believe.rainy-day:link-direction","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"417581e642802beb105d177e67e65e867b8c1479246f3f929c92101a4f29bb1d","supersedes":null}],"merkleRoot":"a76d8a8ff17e6e9a4ae8ec076c5011f3405dd0a6b6b77872664c5a70f276a6c1","serviceSig":{"keyId":"service:a3f979541aee7826","sig":"wGwljaCbC5O6fzQjrhmytqGsQZWWG0vZrfMvYgz2+UHUwosxR8csYXAucR/Y9In1lw2KpteA+Hykmi2gi8mMCg=="},"ownerSig":{"keyId":"SHA256:h82SrxLU1wYr+jpy4Vl9/9iQlAO+HQX1umVBdhy/Ss0","sshsig":"-----BEGIN SSH SIGNATURE-----\nU1NIU0lHAAAAAQAAAGgAAAATZWNkc2Etc2hhMi1uaXN0cDI1NgAAAAhuaXN0cDI1NgAAAE\nEEoxp1EZZ9rp5AYfMO9hQLs04GmJM0haaJgOQhAuCHlPkycB3FgiORcXWBtEUua5jLg16r\npgFNQZQ7R7CMCmON2QAAABJpZGVvbG9neS1pbnRlZ3JpdHkAAAAAAAAABnNoYTUxMgAAAG\nMAAAATZWNkc2Etc2hhMi1uaXN0cDI1NgAAAEgAAAAgTyOn3g1H6Jq1B7DcltjlBnrsKLuN\nWOtcDi+o86TLJxMAAAAgbcZpegoMGsd7rBikeokYn6kl+e9H7vNT74dNexmaFTs=\n-----END SSH SIGNATURE-----\n"},"receipts":[{"witness":"rfc3161","status":"ok","ref":"integrity/receipts/5/rfc3161.tsr"},{"witness":"opentimestamps","status":"pending","ref":"integrity/receipts/5/opentimestamps.ots"}]},"merkleProof":{"index":4,"path":["ced98cd2f96dfeee6e01e4294ea20c9b513e6d89d848bf61572d1adfc75cf0a1","b347d16569cc014da7fc4496c195136a034cfa9d30956f3b56a89e97a131a98c","9ca1acdec1bb76977ef500aca8b4c7abe767aad02aad420b2ebcde872b6083e5"]},"versions":[{"seq":5,"publishedAt":"2026-10-03T05:31:23.125Z","fingerprint":"ced98cd2f96dfeee6e01e4294ea20c9b513e6d89d848bf61572d1adfc75cf0a1","supersedes":null}]}}]}