{"edition":"ca-2026","kind":"claim","id":"ca-prop-42-claim-2","record":{"id":"ca-prop-42-claim-2","subjectId":"ca-prop-42","text":"California’s Constitution currently allows the Legislature to tax the value of our personal property like retirement funds and savings accounts, even though residents already pay income tax on that money when they earn it.","textLanguage":"en","translation":{"he":"החוקה של קליפורניה מאפשרת כיום לבית המחוקקים להטיל מס על שווי הרכוש האישי שלנו, כמו קרנות פרישה וחשבונות חיסכון, אף שהתושבים כבר משלמים מס הכנסה על הכסף הזה כשהם מרוויחים אותו."},"speaker":{"en":"Official argument in favor of Proposition 42","he":"הטיעון הרשמי בעד הצעה 42"},"seenIn":{"kind":"voter-guide-argument","description":{"en":"Official Voter Information Guide, argument in favor of Proposition 42","he":"מדריך המידע הרשמי לבוחר, הטיעון בעד הצעה 42"},"url":"https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/42/arguments-rebuttals.htm","paidFor":null},"verdict":"missing-context","explanation":{"en":"The Analyst says both the state and local governments tax the ownership of certain personal property today (the vehicle license fee and county property taxes on business equipment are examples), and that ownership of financial assets such as stocks and investment accounts is not taxed: the state taxes the income from them, but there is no tax for simply owning them. The Analyst describes Proposition 42 as prohibiting \"new\" taxes on financial assets and other personal property, which implies the Constitution does not bar them now. Two points the sentence leaves out: no such tax on retirement funds or savings accounts exists today, and contributions to traditional (pre-tax) 401(k) plans and IRAs are generally not taxed when earned but when withdrawn, so \"already pay income tax on that money when they earn it\" does not describe all retirement money; it fits after-tax savings and Roth accounts better.","he":"לשכת האנליסט אומרת שגם המדינה וגם הרשויות המקומיות מטילות כיום מס על בעלות על רכוש אישי מסוים (אגרת הרישוי לרכב ומסי הרכוש המחוזיים על ציוד עסקי הם דוגמאות), ושבעלות על נכסים פיננסיים כמו מניות וחשבונות השקעה אינה ממוסה: המדינה ממסה את ההכנסה מהם, אבל אין מס על עצם הבעלות עליהם. לשכת האנליסט מתארת את הצעה 42 כאוסרת מסים „חדשים” על נכסים פיננסיים ועל רכוש אישי אחר, ומכאן משתמע שהחוקה אינה אוסרת אותם כיום. שתי נקודות שהמשפט משמיט: מס כזה על קרנות פרישה או על חשבונות חיסכון אינו קיים כיום, והפקדות לתוכניות 401(k) ולחשבונות IRA מסורתיים (לפני מס) בדרך כלל אינן ממוסות כשמרוויחים אותן אלא כשמושכים אותן, כך ש„כבר משלמים מס הכנסה על הכסף הזה כשמרוויחים אותו” אינו מתאר את כל כספי הפרישה; התיאור מתאים יותר לחסכונות אחרי מס ולחשבונות Roth."},"evidence":[{"title":{"en":"Legislative Analyst's analysis of Proposition 42, Official Voter Information Guide","he":"הניתוח של לשכת האנליסט של בית המחוקקים (LAO) להצעה 42, מדריך המידע הרשמי לבוחר"},"url":"https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/42/analysis.htm"},{"title":{"en":"Attorney General's title and summary of Proposition 42, with the Analyst's fiscal estimate, Official Voter Information Guide","he":"הכותרת והתקציר של התובע הכללי להצעה 42, עם ההערכה הפיסקלית של לשכת האנליסט, מדריך המידע הרשמי לבוחר"},"url":"https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/42/title-summary.htm"},{"title":{"en":"Text of Proposed Laws, Proposition 42 (Retirement and Personal Savings Protection Act of 2026), Official Voter Information Guide","he":"נוסח החוקים המוצעים, הצעה 42 (Retirement and Personal Savings Protection Act of 2026, חוק ההגנה על חסכונות פרישה וחסכונות אישיים, 2026), מדריך המידע הרשמי לבוחר"},"url":"https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop42-text-proposed-laws.pdf"},{"title":{"en":"Internal Revenue Service, Traditional IRAs (contributions may be deductible; distributions are generally taxed)","he":"רשות המסים הפדרלית (Internal Revenue Service), חשבונות IRA מסורתיים (ההפקדות עשויות להיות מוכרות לניכוי; המשיכות בדרך כלל ממוסות)"},"url":"https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/traditional-iras"}],"sourceUrl":"https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/42/arguments-rebuttals.htm","sourceTitle":{"en":"Official Voter Information Guide, November 3, 2026 General Election: arguments and rebuttals on Proposition 42","he":"מדריך המידע הרשמי לבוחר, הבחירות הכלליות ב־3 בנובמבר 2026: טיעונים וטיעוני תשובה על הצעה 42"},"sourceDate":"2026-09-30","archiveUrl":"https://web.archive.org/web/20261001005838/https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/42/arguments-rebuttals.htm","sourcedBy":"sourcer:ca-2026-measures"},"fingerprint":"2a70ebc089928d35db1d7937f8a5fe509ae3355716f01998cdc9779d44bf95c9","proof":{"id":"ca-prop-42-claim-2","edition":"ca-2026","fingerprint":"2a70ebc089928d35db1d7937f8a5fe509ae3355716f01998cdc9779d44bf95c9","entry":{"seq":9,"prev":"c654879e6d3dc2ee5170236cf73eea1d59902742867a44f0422307546be067b0","edition":"ca-2026","publishedAt":"2026-10-03T23:09:41.521Z","records":[{"id":"allen","kind":"content","fingerprint":"add1c06f56bc7ea2c140e4e957ef60a4e898b09554baa14f650180a0956a5533","supersedes":"cdfb54574bfdfd4be03f2f2084d7eaab59e337631a0ac4217a66015dfd9f41c7"},{"id":"allen-insurance","kind":"content","fingerprint":"3dbc5dc14c4cdf7d33b853448be1fb6c3b4d53a925d1c88486a7ea9bc18d5575","supersedes":"7e96cfc1dce5c5113856359523c3768e7b9d073c5da6f1111517cacb10dc329e"},{"id":"barrera","kind":"content","fingerprint":"b9751186a0795cb4aaefcf5d7aa3f00a8991c3548e6fc19531c504304200440d","supersedes":"aa26f9629aecb3b6ac2a8a745200ccc237489a4ba326da4794a54cbfd2e24d00"},{"id":"barrera-schools","kind":"content","fingerprint":"21ddf87236cdfd261f557a131919b6c9085c975b818a300467d35dd39b08a503","supersedes":"9eb71f1661c87cb686396719531bdd2d8745555af8075b41a230f237b86338ea"},{"id":"becerra","kind":"content","fingerprint":"59edef82706a1f853abf85d78ee82219f8813eda079baf69988c8140b222aa32","supersedes":"0a0705b421716f62c9f25bb084327545d7f0cbb7b772edab76aa55048e5d6772"},{"id":"becerra-abortion","kind":"content","fingerprint":"0deb2d8926c9126cfa5598de60bc519aefb87e8dccc70997dd7e46585cdf4798","supersedes":"607ea8e2a914e4cd20581ec538aa5e3656f638bfb87d694f4daa1aa6a9c3c88d"},{"id":"becerra-climate","kind":"content","fingerprint":"0fbfda3a1aee2d6721642a12d3bc97ffff5e2a7857eb64209a90a849f88822e4","supersedes":"51f03b2c6c2d1abc4ae560b9dae4a75d6a43ae99367db32663199d84d6675b7f"},{"id":"becerra-healthcare","kind":"content","fingerprint":"19163fe082fd160d8e3920f0cd85da0259ebab12e58877ef7285a997a402ec17","supersedes":"502457d39a3e31997a1215a602b3f2b97519bd090fd2594e78e24a877da21347"},{"id":"ca-hilton-claim-1","kind":"content","fingerprint":"72d19a0e353c9febf0487f4a08e5d5aeedf61e6d6dc3ce64b496c30f0da7e2ab","supersedes":"15c1c508c505317b8a2b905d65726fd4bcaec9518383d8baa41b21a23ec0e58f"},{"id":"ca-prop-1","kind":"content","fingerprint":"6089082cc3dfea1f0c1c0e1be50142ef804505add010e359a1a1590dcf306f8c","supersedes":"3baa0f720bf4d6ee5a7020127369ed9c21aa1b127bb901d1d6a89902590b6635"},{"id":"ca-prop-1-claim-1","kind":"content","fingerprint":"bd51bf5fa5aa722e758e8e42a26266f6aa5b9f33b6d73e4b6fbe9d021245abae","supersedes":"ae53d382b8167ed6c9ffb04dfec19bc4a905a7ae498ad8e48b8f422588d4c907"},{"id":"ca-prop-1-claim-2","kind":"content","fingerprint":"ab24fff8ee2b702645015f55b504550ae4471e3ffddaa816f18bb7dc9cb0cdae","supersedes":"e3e14e14a1ec48814af5ccc2eeae8c42dc68f31345296b47e8205ed422194b6c"},{"id":"ca-prop-2","kind":"content","fingerprint":"7be689bce4e10321423c5129af17e62d8e1d1101322d464edd15541929b3b213","supersedes":"8cc0229b9b61ce02f97aec56064e914acee6a9253507d7f25380cede35e981ed"},{"id":"ca-prop-2-claim-1","kind":"content","fingerprint":"c95b506439c7f6ffc8757f132c159b14ad32a023f5236ef39d3bec89ca1bbe93","supersedes":"624acee71fec254465379afcc319e0245101d32df8660a337aad45f6a1ea0ce0"},{"id":"ca-prop-2-claim-2","kind":"content","fingerprint":"f43251d6b6f4007882fdb15875f5bfb3f0a761a0b3a40c0de0baa4765a4e9ecc","supersedes":"b0a51f669ac513ffe31fef62a75196ea26591c3f62b8e5596eaeee22dc4dbab4"},{"id":"ca-prop-2-claim-3","kind":"content","fingerprint":"20b7e97648c58209292c4a1f85fb68fb4781ea138d23b676639807a5d7043ffc","supersedes":"cd1876e858fbfe022ab5499c0f54250a516a84a97f9149a78a81668990d6fd8f"},{"id":"ca-prop-2-claim-4","kind":"content","fingerprint":"809e1523e57d5a2261fe97d40afaafb1804d8ae1ddfd5378b06bd532a3d7b5ba","supersedes":"aef73d1125c7d76ff6daf2e361a923cfeaf3c80c25a5950dbcbcd1bed621682f"},{"id":"ca-prop-3","kind":"content","fingerprint":"73c8b4b19fcf1a2400262cdb99f4ecec7594ffb27c91fc4e7c9e93c0e1a0aeb3","supersedes":"64e80ce98b9164d2c3e7587890556300109e4ec4c70732185eff00bfd786155e"},{"id":"ca-prop-3-claim-1","kind":"content","fingerprint":"57cb84b10c41c026863f5fc32a971620990ffccac78e8af3d6db9c2844ef2349","supersedes":"3aef0a859e53d4898fb7b824d6105522b20f9f7584aac74afe83982dfe258f4e"},{"id":"ca-prop-3-claim-2","kind":"content","fingerprint":"3045aa2ad7b76f08f9c18dc002e5ae0c4e5de57c6d2b66c4e9e206625add250b","supersedes":"2147138a742ff37f248d0cca701fd511c53638ced618fe44a2f607f1f201a22c"},{"id":"ca-prop-3-claim-3","kind":"content","fingerprint":"9f0aedba6122a95039983a9cfaecad8e8f7e80c404ef8fb058c2310567de2b15","supersedes":"2f216e4fb1b5d7bb8ae95320e90f5ffa35ae454d8dd786a3e6ae71003880ee5c"},{"id":"ca-prop-3-claim-4","kind":"content","fingerprint":"d42bf8e478c044caebc2efed878ccc9eb8690a23b15a39d94a0f98a3e9b2f32a","supersedes":"0457da1cdb75a2c669c7c4b090d4f2fed3c3cc6c98a1ad0f020cbc7c4556adfd"},{"id":"ca-prop-3-claim-5","kind":"content","fingerprint":"4afcfb13f2e02643294ed7dc2ca4bad03cab8748d8e6c8ee075979562c2d2007","supersedes":"ac5b1202800b5446ab14dda36f13526040f3a00bc6d70bc75197f1b980e1d91c"},{"id":"ca-prop-37","kind":"content","fingerprint":"5d0ec1b1510ab347a3e5feaad629ec3a202db173ae2846e1828cc92cfa13a259","supersedes":"511ee8eb7de1652b1403f19ac9cb8b0984d02bf44e966bf9a00157568996eccd"},{"id":"ca-prop-37-claim-1","kind":"content","fingerprint":"b741e2715eca8130547e8d60cc99b2b5f13e7ff28d05b14ed5d7bdec8cec0f19","supersedes":"f82f02ac62427085324702f7056be867e236a2f715ef08c154f8a95197ba06c1"},{"id":"ca-prop-37-claim-2","kind":"content","fingerprint":"dad1645dfa98de386692d77315f9e6b767d3c980f1c5f41a510c6a9be9f8bd12","supersedes":"8d148254676c0c5f42a06b28b98ea75b4e4cf2fb19c46d4d2832b837e997a183"},{"id":"ca-prop-38","kind":"content","fingerprint":"0bd5b285dc3a68719b852080131c75042e7f18321ad2d57e9693bd2f4ccfeed9","supersedes":"40328031e8db3bbf9605bf7326857e0639b1439161121e4380d61ff5ccb46da5"},{"id":"ca-prop-38-claim-1","kind":"content","fingerprint":"f6c7d874d0f6b509c4a8510b8a631646e531eb8d6d1b0f9448c0ac4bd7532cb0","supersedes":"c4935066085d09474dc4d514f0c5f743f65f0bcecd578434ea5f0b5be4443f67"},{"id":"ca-prop-38-claim-2","kind":"content","fingerprint":"a93cc4a565954adb58eb84db3217c53d4e511205402da73b4c020de7db6e24f2","supersedes":"1523b8d0a1c16b8a5f58989504dfcb3bbcfa707fbd85f770f5539ef4a1cade1b"},{"id":"ca-prop-38-claim-3","kind":"content","fingerprint":"2433223e957deb2ce059e34748b9af489888766070b812139a32a17708adc074","supersedes":"3edf4c0dd06693a49a13745db66d9851a233254a4fb88b15f9c1244f91464397"},{"id":"ca-prop-39","kind":"content","fingerprint":"1755cf6df9378f1936a28942253c977baedd383fbdca20e5303ab2ef72e43ca9","supersedes":"9d652b0d49970c171a7f055eefb50183c15b083dc12407e763a2ebb3a895e24c"},{"id":"ca-prop-39-claim-1","kind":"content","fingerprint":"a6b79afd13730435d5455194e0dda8578a3eff3890e1801ef18e5e82e51ab9d6","supersedes":"c68cfc57bfa2bb2254d5c4e244388ab37da52a6449dab3298319f3a50cd796bc"},{"id":"ca-prop-39-claim-2","kind":"content","fingerprint":"2f989f1ab1e82f25889248cdf00178f4e93cb9a85c8dcb07161ae236fb573cbe","supersedes":"c060cf44def4141ec0bfc1b40a108d9a997978189cb5d52c3d194fb8d5d42276"},{"id":"ca-prop-39-claim-3","kind":"content","fingerprint":"9f1d450109312a83e70f37a1d7689a6df6770e2b70c7af5d18cf5b7027f19379","supersedes":"3fcc9707da4355740f039cedd8a49cb92e833dddbd5a0076784c6e641ee7900c"},{"id":"ca-prop-39-claim-4","kind":"content","fingerprint":"56d8c6fdfd4ecdb2fa2ad910046a7f3e8d76f9df10f5602200226b871eaed8e6","supersedes":"721cd87a2e4d4d3bef12e931298dfcdb9b0de1139d26b06214e4b852226b23d7"},{"id":"ca-prop-4","kind":"content","fingerprint":"954d4d359909047554942221190f6ff5c99716244f575cc61a70a19b24575431","supersedes":"91f56779de16819c8dd9d0dbe34524565be62d190eb60ae64aaf3eda1e914a89"},{"id":"ca-prop-4-claim-1","kind":"content","fingerprint":"df771bb2de311a62f9b83fffbb0c61164e0d1a98d87bc5cc6c94ff750246d5ce","supersedes":"14f43ee566863c75b2a411d9ececc401e0f0f929ba7423da568dd713bba08c1f"},{"id":"ca-prop-4-claim-2","kind":"content","fingerprint":"6b35388ee1cc28b96599cb4d83d3e3e742639a1166ddc7fd12def3bc8f2a3a89","supersedes":"362dd104e9d3c97022ae5104b5e786355ec79ed5a6ec43b2fda9a3e2d24e668a"},{"id":"ca-prop-40","kind":"content","fingerprint":"6d713ab879c1d9c3b0478a6bedb24ca6958811eefa600a04f8a8168b416f8131","supersedes":"88ac703decb6c32df0eb8daeec2a295174c4bebbfec737399aed9f778c7464e0"},{"id":"ca-prop-40-claim-1","kind":"content","fingerprint":"076391834a33e6cac381534b6797e3adaf399b4fe82c16c493937da7aacc0ac8","supersedes":"70215e1ac77acd4ecab411e1b4199145db5fd2347ceae71abd483472fc8d4bd2"},{"id":"ca-prop-40-claim-2","kind":"content","fingerprint":"098cf921c7039c56a4705346889009ed86cda15f2adcbd141af1a14c05ecd0df","supersedes":"0bad917c341df0449d5cbbaaedd4bac2b2ad4815960e0fd0f714eb5eff359ce2"},{"id":"ca-prop-40-claim-3","kind":"content","fingerprint":"5ba49bd1c1503231948d23cdcb50d358f7720c3d27e54a761f68682f2af06d26","supersedes":"8c883a6dec0fef88b56ad8ef41a42dd091a108544b1c1aa22eb40cb3943097ea"},{"id":"ca-prop-40-claim-4","kind":"content","fingerprint":"9f0eb1e3dc2fe8b2a78224a9d6e429b8a36fb065e24dc42f7b2a3e1e60337332","supersedes":"db3559c81e2b28eb15b499f554b7bb81b63a5e74e4b28eca8f43337a2d8969e2"},{"id":"ca-prop-40-claim-5","kind":"content","fingerprint":"5c9b3b66ecd22fb8ea20087ba77a763050b50e11388ce76e3d0db754188caa82","supersedes":"d009c6cd34d9bcdf7d46aba6d79c99ec2ea65d483ad9c0c4d56d4c03de9dd5fe"},{"id":"ca-prop-40-claim-6","kind":"content","fingerprint":"54cb36cd9ce66555f0ffec12dd48892d25d9a61aa4d06f0b155ee0ec9cbe0ceb","supersedes":"cfc2908f8b10d1bd21e82f7d054facd95ef1bd44bd738a5c2fae1c524989e0e2"},{"id":"ca-prop-41","kind":"content","fingerprint":"97f6dfddcefbae998683f622f0da5a57e6edadec293dbb4715b90321b3aceeb4","supersedes":"03bb2475f5c51e5506f044c935e747254ded5e12270160281703119fa19188c2"},{"id":"ca-prop-41-claim-1","kind":"content","fingerprint":"a64d93468cf94f575c8edc7931b4f79b50b78a283fd4770689e9049ab6c1953b","supersedes":"75f921a93c1193dbb78dea68ec941f9f3e44b50cac6c839c4c521e02b6f0cce5"},{"id":"ca-prop-41-claim-2","kind":"content","fingerprint":"6b696574b8662ba5b70cee37f8aeb9e0c2be03150ad6f66946f45a22577b2918","supersedes":"c59b61842335d6a78daf9d15ca307fca56b808ea992e7d120d0b16afb86a1e85"},{"id":"ca-prop-41-claim-3","kind":"content","fingerprint":"aff0bb61f6cd6a865f479c6a7c9937c716e35b25d43f3daf7833e8244c650a62","supersedes":"34c7950b7d2489d24712a3b8908b86dcc1765eb7b6f6a82e5cde9758b9563037"},{"id":"ca-prop-41-claim-4","kind":"content","fingerprint":"e23fd8511699265fdf837187eb666fb5e2b5c99343cc5cd365c72c914d2db1c1","supersedes":"44da199500544018ed2fb140e8ebe867a768f3fc712d59b4f817e9d63682043a"},{"id":"ca-prop-42","kind":"content","fingerprint":"c1ab6e463c9a1f60a22fe58cfc23c7bf1c7e9485716d75ea1e1866ab9bc99acc","supersedes":"960f107875fd4bbd711fde7b36fe113edd9cd8578bedb7f8c1bc116c9a7dfb6c"},{"id":"ca-prop-42-claim-1","kind":"content","fingerprint":"96fea6427764e601d2ab44b557389935a2f22b174645f5357ac0c9f041aa7203","supersedes":"199a60eba4a26a715ac916286aad9ec6156dcbf7b5834d596ac0407ec26c0db5"},{"id":"ca-prop-42-claim-2","kind":"content","fingerprint":"2a70ebc089928d35db1d7937f8a5fe509ae3355716f01998cdc9779d44bf95c9","supersedes":"68f23a92f0f3422a52466f45f3aa9c620529656fae3b9c99348f639f1a1b52e7"},{"id":"ca-prop-42-claim-3","kind":"content","fingerprint":"9b77b7df65617d9675d94dd02758a6913510a918de025b8fc3f4ff5080a9c552","supersedes":"2557fbab91b8e5e5027b46e47e3bbaf594ffefbe13a39ccf4770f9fb084918aa"},{"id":"ca-prop-42-claim-4","kind":"content","fingerprint":"27cb96fbf7dc3ff9cba37773a7c77bfd824b0a9f635a0c08093ec19fcee15f01","supersedes":"2bf74421e6fd1e8dbd6e09eeeb733e91eb1b8b78e2d6de05bbba357b7c0087c5"},{"id":"ca-prop-42-claim-5","kind":"content","fingerprint":"4d6b261284b2dda855e7c6fa51920e3e8884f63867d429aecad94e91f4b100d4","supersedes":"84d4f7fd04903b93d7cf9d725f03a6e13676f98f65dcdee21bcfc124d19c3293"},{"id":"ca-prop-42-claim-sms-1","kind":"content","fingerprint":"d2f8940b6d1dc2e539151414363513994582ef4c527814900eb251637196024e","supersedes":"854572e0e3cf60a13cfa7480e5e07f979c332278922cb945447c54f44fb9bff3"},{"id":"ca-prop-43","kind":"content","fingerprint":"96ea5b22c80cd5eb447db7a71e27f2c5b9343d81ddd3d8837a34360c8ea8befb","supersedes":"8215a7ee53efe911a0b7f24e8ddb3f13d04002574464ff33fc89442ee8085598"},{"id":"ca-prop-43-claim-1","kind":"content","fingerprint":"4f0f19d8e6d09a350da911574c8bd90a3be8fc733029fb9620305978f88a42ff","supersedes":"e76dd1b23eae1faff454fb067d54eb62e6c1ff6127c168742ee548227654bb75"},{"id":"ca-prop-43-claim-2","kind":"content","fingerprint":"246cde12ddfd02b3817a019b93cb6954ae2be0030f5554b5666a868ec18befae","supersedes":"501af5c4e68865b878ac04cabba2804317da4d511bbae933f73db376da4fb874"},{"id":"ca-prop-43-claim-3","kind":"content","fingerprint":"1ae8c4f34cb09ef6496f04659b7fdcffbc0682ef6a39bc704e98a0d1a21e4591","supersedes":"553b41636550ac97fe896c40cc50f6aaced0c48d2d7092287e6a1fef7bf79401"},{"id":"ca-prop-43-claim-4","kind":"content","fingerprint":"8695f9eae0f4602be5b1c3196a44aadaca328a6bc4a8abbaa1cfd67231f299b0","supersedes":"18750108703853cf6c69112f556714d1515f047a0dcd9460c7b3dcc8ed67b614"},{"id":"ca-prop-44","kind":"content","fingerprint":"a912dacac76c58c664283a77bed952ed8438588b253542bb92f1b8fa5d2692c9","supersedes":"b3e21d2d5d6e41ec02a897f6e94e68429fc82836ad2910fac121e250929527ce"},{"id":"ca-prop-44-claim-1","kind":"content","fingerprint":"32455b93ee2641a6f62af5aa64e0a6e7df5003d77a4b128e0726d634c1e6719a","supersedes":"9e3f5caa78a8c577e89afdcfe6e44651f0d1d80bae1a7f79e68a217c51b6ce86"},{"id":"ca-prop-44-claim-2","kind":"content","fingerprint":"5e3dc1281af746c7f7b5cc5ce8ee43892e342d1e24651e19ab43b1f96c568474","supersedes":"117ef0a27b7903bc4cd7b84cfe84efed58b95c9c38aff297087944012c249ceb"},{"id":"ca-prop-44-claim-3","kind":"content","fingerprint":"058887bb0adad8598ed0e26eb944b6bfc2a6b720fbb3f1a74219d2183431157b","supersedes":"fbdfe704f1cc0bd13f1e17c049b772c970f61b664de6e1004b1350de5c906622"},{"id":"ca-prop-44-claim-4","kind":"content","fingerprint":"1d530acea8e59ecfd777c04a20227f0390216d47c7bfe09760e7853875fa1c4f","supersedes":"f041527adb7808fd45c8d033d1df2aa5a89fb681f2e565945554d080d58fa096"},{"id":"ca-prop-45","kind":"content","fingerprint":"8df910b631b3e5ed4fed18a583647a9c8b4c87277b388a00fc1ce2329ff52895","supersedes":"1ddd8f601a5a5bce9d0cc17c5fd607e3bb33f5a9a63f81613a729fa9bee91a2c"},{"id":"ca-prop-45-claim-1","kind":"content","fingerprint":"1e3285c59ad51e536baf602c95e10f5aa7fb29f58f3affb7028bccbe726a9e7f","supersedes":"455f57943f91bb4555cd0ca28bee10492640eba4526d667fbb69bf0b55ea0281"},{"id":"ca-prop-45-claim-2","kind":"content","fingerprint":"82d8cc268c071d59d617bad4d94074e4ccafb594d5e57611f3bef9e77b0b4349","supersedes":"8ab52c1206bc0a6d22a9b0409de5780a9e8377dab7ce1ce719ea2e9c5b12defa"},{"id":"ca-prop-45-claim-3","kind":"content","fingerprint":"bbc0d2afd7767ebf257c4e44a4be82a7c44c478d53b8f84c7ddaa889e893dcf4","supersedes":"164755acb3c1a4853ee4b59e7e00c6a7641e34ff4152bcbd34fe78580d61d786"},{"id":"ca-prop-5","kind":"content","fingerprint":"2aac875af3ed30f8b65e1445013477bf72f0ef9511a77afde8a71291156ef8c4","supersedes":"76e89c174c56c53b826d9dc39c7eff0bfa748c7acb3d35ab45221bb7f691926e"},{"id":"ca-prop-5-claim-1","kind":"content","fingerprint":"a57d6b054992c70497b40442ce9ab676f63d97a7b9324a9402de845249d85713","supersedes":"255358c68eb16a394bca99c6bf53904536cd2886d556646ef781c9dac97a0878"},{"id":"ca-prop-5-claim-2","kind":"content","fingerprint":"73f2385d32854a7781b8a48a62ec335bb1905e73991f6d7dcf3de60b85eaf7f9","supersedes":"d797c7560e5603cd43c2f419b3f67aa07273678197f2e7db358e9b194a684331"},{"id":"hilton","kind":"content","fingerprint":"e29ef67b04a4da0d2f64cacdb96ef01e5e042def91ec5499569c99349bc91c8d","supersedes":"1191ffda4b1bf0589cd23137857d42cf03bae62ff16f3844cccab1ea8bdec070"},{"id":"hilton-climate","kind":"content","fingerprint":"4011c1ad1970fbeccb5c460cac2b57e4d89927710e6163cc12e8e5c7b97e2bdb","supersedes":"ac3a679b130258b56fefbbc1a97a5b25d91c5a5af55bca479291456ea54525c1"},{"id":"hilton-schools","kind":"content","fingerprint":"b675039158f0b799a76892310a4474ce23c9e5b05aec67996f151d52a54b4d5f","supersedes":"d5c175cc0ecaa8f820e5d7c8a4a920f500c3cca4116f5c30cd761ca3cfcd15d7"},{"id":"hilton-spending","kind":"content","fingerprint":"27d5e5356d4a440379c5ae03b84862b30410938b357ea324859b8f0bc1c04f44","supersedes":"c8ac2fa69bf7effb2cb8f4a4620b7127c27f7574cfd8607521a77356ed90f60d"},{"id":"hilton-tax","kind":"content","fingerprint":"1db9a202ff217f03045dbb02659c8b51f4eb0f88a869fc600129fbb22427f642","supersedes":"1383fc2f9c23ddb55b6345fe19bc5e392d1e3972c31b330119c9f3b63dcb42cf"},{"id":"kim","kind":"content","fingerprint":"fbd405093f11352986f2801b1b1a96a0b1355d8d15013200edbad4588ca5711f","supersedes":"23a65795fcd34b4e21edfc24f90a1f1c77efd185e4af3fc58e1c77e8aba6e111"},{"id":"kim-healthcare","kind":"content","fingerprint":"ef382015c67f289cdd6a30b25d05657787c93090fad41aa76eb2871d110bb08e","supersedes":"bb4f728e155d08d38cb4e2aa9e0930530d1517b7649228b5e7b25b396cb6c422"},{"id":"kim-insurance","kind":"content","fingerprint":"9522110ad748f28f37c417ab9242dad8ce47c004a57d2149380358d6b6721e83","supersedes":"e071dbf864bf7e67ef76f9268c2fec82ea08674238b8a3c70e925b54fe2bd622"},{"id":"shaw","kind":"content","fingerprint":"cc1d2aa8f3594f327a5860d33b1a1c7af7306b615456773a246a6519b4ef1337","supersedes":"6705ccfc8c54e792eeeeb113010dda1654406717d920ba2a4ba78dec89d42538"},{"id":"shaw-sports","kind":"content","fingerprint":"c2b713c8e38087b35ed02833352de917a24442f19258b9dd1d93264783f24185","supersedes":"7c3a3a55c155c2f8814f4bc438594ae559a28a3f08b732edfd4822c74d424e7c"}],"merkleRoot":"510fa346bc644ee6942848357c92ed2869f227a8977c9bcc638184f371d8cee4","serviceSig":{"keyId":"service:a3f979541aee7826","sig":"oVuZkvgRx+7+xd0BfzNa9hsyZnZKSqIvpKlg8J0cqBLvZuOWY3yX6fdZ4J11jwOXs2FkPoX4/ry9oxaWfllQBg=="},"ownerSig":{"keyId":"SHA256:h82SrxLU1wYr+jpy4Vl9/9iQlAO+HQX1umVBdhy/Ss0","sshsig":"-----BEGIN SSH SIGNATURE-----\nU1NIU0lHAAAAAQAAAGgAAAATZWNkc2Etc2hhMi1uaXN0cDI1NgAAAAhuaXN0cDI1NgAAAE\nEEoxp1EZZ9rp5AYfMO9hQLs04GmJM0haaJgOQhAuCHlPkycB3FgiORcXWBtEUua5jLg16r\npgFNQZQ7R7CMCmON2QAAABJpZGVvbG9neS1pbnRlZ3JpdHkAAAAAAAAABnNoYTUxMgAAAG\nQAAAATZWNkc2Etc2hhMi1uaXN0cDI1NgAAAEkAAAAhANw2u5E49dIIkEI+dlD5uuhdq1CQ\nT6dU+0H7E3D2WGXAAAAAIHGISf4QNN78fOlfgMg5MtGJdXwkHsgT91SiI1RfKa4i\n-----END SSH SIGNATURE-----\n"},"receipts":[{"witness":"rfc3161","status":"ok","ref":"integrity/receipts/9/rfc3161.tsr"},{"witness":"opentimestamps","status":"pending","ref":"integrity/receipts/9/opentimestamps.ots"}]},"merkleProof":{"index":18,"path":["2aac875af3ed30f8b65e1445013477bf72f0ef9511a77afde8a71291156ef8c4","18ce3bb90e1c0580614327e062a0d4886958bbd8b3a12a5c04f58c2eecf1a68b","88aaf48aa818b03efa6fe888954952aef9ca6812a9f7b2c6645e963b499ee3f1","b3c8534bdd8c231849269c8ccdb08b80b9efb478347600af7660452a33f665a1","f1b3ed3845674a4203d7f8f0dd7d660be14afe2219829fa711d48f2357eb2d55","501380cb2bdf3d78d0eb3521019289180d3bc10cb24193e13bec8a9e8b297d94","9b8ab8130fcfeac8d80c79834555c9c5576e160a7aaf347dc90223422cabe0fb"]},"versions":[{"seq":2,"publishedAt":"2026-10-03T05:05:39.350Z","fingerprint":"68f23a92f0f3422a52466f45f3aa9c620529656fae3b9c99348f639f1a1b52e7","supersedes":null},{"seq":9,"publishedAt":"2026-10-03T23:09:41.521Z","fingerprint":"2a70ebc089928d35db1d7937f8a5fe509ae3355716f01998cdc9779d44bf95c9","supersedes":"68f23a92f0f3422a52466f45f3aa9c620529656fae3b9c99348f639f1a1b52e7"}]},"judgments":[{"id":"ca-prop-42-claim-2:claim-verdict","record":{"id":"ca-prop-42-claim-2:claim-verdict","subjectId":"ca-prop-42-claim-2","kind":"claim-verdict","tier":"result","call":"missing-context","rationale":{"en":"The Analyst says both the state and local governments tax the ownership of certain personal property today (the vehicle license fee and county property taxes on business equipment are examples), and that ownership of financial assets such as stocks and investment accounts is not taxed: the state taxes the income from them, but there is no tax for simply owning them. The Analyst describes Proposition 42 as prohibiting \"new\" taxes on financial assets and other personal property, which implies the Constitution does not bar them now. Two points the sentence leaves out: no such tax on retirement funds or savings accounts exists today, and contributions to traditional (pre-tax) 401(k) plans and IRAs are generally not taxed when earned but when withdrawn, so \"already pay income tax on that money when they earn it\" does not describe all retirement money; it fits after-tax savings and Roth accounts better."},"alternatives":[],"author":"sourcer:ca-2026-measures","panelDecisionId":null,"supersedes":null},"fingerprint":"0ef4f0a291310f1b301262eb4ee11586debc9ce3774f1ffe0a242dbb009a499a","proof":{"id":"ca-prop-42-claim-2:claim-verdict","edition":"ca-2026","fingerprint":"0ef4f0a291310f1b301262eb4ee11586debc9ce3774f1ffe0a242dbb009a499a","entry":{"seq":6,"prev":"c347c763bdae729d39b6f2c15fdfafc8c19dd4352fffeeb79b6c41f6e024741d","edition":"ca-2026","publishedAt":"2026-10-03T05:31:23.125Z","records":[{"id":"allen-insurance:position-side","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"a48ba1874267099b3bda5bec00440c91463b0d38e2081d6c9f09709251f9132a","supersedes":null},{"id":"allen:inclusion","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"299172d44be1ab53ebb24555e4d502979a8bea179b3f36083493715c86fc0c06","supersedes":null},{"id":"barrera-schools:position-side","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"a8bf64563202485082cb245edcb254ae6e22465bf60f64b57945fab18d2845cb","supersedes":null},{"id":"barrera:inclusion","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"66662312e191d0038634de607e3ecc73620ec815d363734b0aa3e72f78f25a27","supersedes":null},{"id":"becerra-abortion:position-side","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"ebf10fafaafb24db9f3544caad5615e3b2c06c583dc973c5044f0188a4a621e7","supersedes":null},{"id":"becerra-climate:position-side","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"eeb05b95fe77af27c74fbbf5505d2642192009aa63fdd46ccb04efc7bb9b7afe","supersedes":null},{"id":"becerra-healthcare:position-side","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"4f6a15bb91ff1bba42782b438971eb3578c999e3698bd2b6fdf5d9580a9f0bad","supersedes":null},{"id":"becerra:inclusion","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"ce4983f5c907efca7bd35a50e04bcea19a4f7786193f62ff8923cd7ac684dc07","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-hilton-claim-1:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"d7f41a3a6ebc99748d382f85eaf8e9c8d7a5b321ef340e5370319a4e36b1cbbd","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-1-claim-1:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"3af620ce20744aa936d8b7dfd85a955312710c2e4fc8438659067f3302011a8d","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-1-claim-2:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"27fe295de04e2eebdfee6beed0a923489f1f31ffa686854fbc67b8227e1f45ae","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-1@believe.borrowing:link-direction","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"22ed44d3722d7be6206ee1cf626696bff94959beb109e57ed65c8b2e092ad830","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-2-claim-1:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"1d26b622c11fc056415b8096e3bb83d82921cf66b952357a50dc292bc36e29f0","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-2-claim-2:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"5dae3331d4f782b417d7763cd94de5cdee498f70f8e86e159743a7a8afaf64e7","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-2-claim-3:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"e45d458be03fdcb3642742288218c37cc59ab004589fc53ccd8f585c67697722","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-2-claim-4:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"c847c6a106dc3d614d8bf50d70100202c592656de5fece1db3ae5b6d928be93f","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-2@believe.rainy-day:link-direction","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"c227d2dedc98b00971953ef587591b8af1a38d8a9c156edae7d0e1133b27af2e","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-3-claim-1:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"799d3a20b4784b1293ddb0a67f39aab667fe57b2b56a2ce22a93d194b0afb443","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-3-claim-2:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"0c5eec619e3bba92333148b97f6973109d9d764e7cd52f2ba3af3f8008a16545","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-3-claim-3:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"e1c6e4c28f6a8adf401a2436b8578857cb2f7669efe764a01317b5d8103588aa","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-3-claim-4:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"da83db1c37d0367693daddbf3eaee2e94724f2904b064b454f2012fa84b19e12","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-3-claim-5:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"89adf2a00b650c43e0a969eed94bf27bdc25939a3019e408d04afd8980e836fb","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-37-claim-1:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"12f989c808b6e386e251cbe19f71724f3e030b619bd9922433729b914cf206c9","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-37-claim-2:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"94f6491afcf80b487bdd9257e3bbc9f5e3343dc435de71f20c88dca647769e35","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-38-claim-1:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"83c3889ca4926d126778ecc8f31943170953be6f3df0288f310efcee893e6546","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-38-claim-2:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"a807f07fad273cf5bb949e3c7010c918086fa5820e7ce471732e8859f093a0a7","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-38-claim-3:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"ca80c5c986872e492b8695a8452a8366e5178478892cf4d69d46115cefa58436","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-38@believe.borrowing:link-direction","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"f1168a73e61a44e570dadd6fd59b9b8da39676c3e1597392b99a26c4d1bc4b54","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-39-claim-1:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"99f0bd94e8eb9072818768c7f82759ed9c6aec512198ce57f4bc90998e3c393c","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-39-claim-2:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"b26043c1ad784910e7d1d2b0e962424d152440007b1fc3d6d8cac4d91d20841d","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-39-claim-3:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"9b7180dfac3cdc110fe5930c62ff1b6707304ebbe7b018fedbf7f5f625d33bd2","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-39-claim-4:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"ca5703a6b824dbe6595c3a43fca18c733719bc96bc00c1657411afbbaf5a7c28","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-39@believe.voting-rules-eligible:link-direction","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"2c5b209ce11c106f23d793039235ce0d1ad9732a0c010373586f7b84c0fd1d9e","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-3@believe.tax-share:link-direction","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"a367fc8a360c5e8dbcbd8edce1378ddfbeff7a444127c38741755805d72008f0","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-4-claim-1:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"7fa3629f8e1cf897e569d6d54a9b6d70a9bcabe3ed13614dd22469161e6e2414","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-4-claim-2:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"28194cb0401c0ea155af7b7acaa74fb7d2e4d2e818ea9202a5bc2792669d6cd3","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-40-claim-1:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"4cf726756c6a99d844cf59463b198bfa47af2162487bc04e9f8f17d89d99a73b","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-40-claim-2:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"90018c43bbd44b7ab051a4133a5065bf8e8e4a6cad9945baf9e61551d1d4cb27","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-40-claim-3:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"8cda8fd5f2427a13a7ed0f1268392f17c4c49c1aa7d9576d8dd1690da71c83f2","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-40-claim-4:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"9dc53bf4b3325aa1c6d31238456406704a9f057338e4f2e6c41fe77898ba441c","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-40-claim-5:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"ccb5d20c3ade2cdc2b85251da6b248fda5d6c147ebc3f8c334cf939ed2d8d0db","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-40-claim-6:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"290ad88df669ae4fabc8f0e017263d1f0372421fd57b354aaee8872806260a00","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-40@believe.tax-share:link-direction","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"04ce4c7d614d5378cdb610328ad704766bd79e14f57255fa2213d244f3cb316c","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-41-claim-1:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"5dee1bc8caa040b0de5132eabbceb8d5a5565d871b912cf5bae5c6af9cd2363d","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-41-claim-2:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"06ab441368adf753b78feb8a55b17d4699df22cd45dd4a787c07ac6948ae41fa","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-41-claim-3:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"e513f05a0017c6283d5d4aa2016b0457d0c108663077e0cccacb716c2909e8c0","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-41-claim-4:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"e16f4947fc88be8fc20b3e641ada3b3b858932b09c0b5b67d3d3f44e15386d11","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-42-claim-1:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"c652957e4666a116e21c9a053d26b39e35d7d31394bc4d12852bec77d13623c8","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-42-claim-2:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"0ef4f0a291310f1b301262eb4ee11586debc9ce3774f1ffe0a242dbb009a499a","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-42-claim-3:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"782d5491f1808dcf26624c8b4330abb2ebdbb4b36836cb7a90d5363d8eb657d4","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-42-claim-4:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"16658abab3c6d87d43fc9afce5dd8cbe4892e2b8fc3798f74cd952378c0fbbc2","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-42-claim-5:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"76051b0d2563b33d3df57cef842c0a9fd5f5673ce3c7b36cd39a9fd8f60d3d81","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-42-claim-sms-1:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"1ad68549d9724d03f0fe15e69aed8f922a65aa4b4de9d6c4f264a0d813052918","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-43-claim-1:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"f28de08d3cdc10d69a612681e27a8d74411f68754ada67015b4ac95c80d31fd9","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-43-claim-2:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"96d1886c3d2895e38b4bd4da37eb5a08b3d6309d38e9a7662f1bb8e754606e0e","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-43-claim-3:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"21cb6549b91c11288e94153121a1ac8f4aa1fd12b580c514035d05e1d1340a01","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-43-claim-4:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"8a77cb3b7e3cc8fef9ca80adb59befd9cc7338a14fae0eebca4cbda12a751be6","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-43@believe.tax-threshold:link-direction","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"1d01f3dff77f2afaa843051c7c70f763b64e667851fce082afd54a9f7047233b","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-44-claim-1:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"dfcf5694bb1094feae64ab19a64f372c78f0b4f14e46011c1409889c73f7a8a4","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-44-claim-2:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"28314b7683b25d6ec13a037adcaa80064c9a49d93e7429d97109da371f1427fb","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-44-claim-3:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"b86c310fd1b2391df57eb01404d8a9135a7cd1a3b1f4d61d7214dacde500c255","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-44-claim-4:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"9cc9d4c360c5c6d3cf08e08055603d8b5d4ec1e0fa56c7512b55ddc3d43f1e65","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-45-claim-1:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"06c098d0df8453aa4b0656d27c962367b598d37bbe41a63342876a26abf37a8c","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-45-claim-2:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"ad96dc9f2079de36d2d1383eeabcc650706e18667cd4b6fa9a498f041ef15db3","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-45-claim-3:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"6bb2a3240dd37dbd12a71cf7a71621dc6be02c01af6df87153efff8d41cf48ec","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-45@believe.project-review:link-direction","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"26cec9ad98476b4608a41095671daa2a0a1967517627b1e3aca02ae89b4e6b2c","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-4@believe.campaign-money:link-direction","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"7df8a53e4274cb32bbc4dde0da2d2cad275b92861f9c472a3f5fe954cd9e5012","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-5-claim-1:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"c4d072be3fae22194229061ca96560f34410982e93f9c4b63e58aa1394e53796","supersedes":null},{"id":"ca-prop-5-claim-2:claim-verdict","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"53c266e75527ade6a5085d3ee752e97ec854130517dbca010753a3171f2d0a96","supersedes":null},{"id":"hilton-climate:position-side","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"dada4e45c34e7ee11cfbd2b54e17bac78283acae3c5f30b7ecbc869ce2250084","supersedes":null},{"id":"hilton-schools:position-side","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"fa951cccb048657a29dbebded0836f593abaa461a308c1c8a8a9bd82f4a2285f","supersedes":null},{"id":"hilton-spending:position-side","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"3d0e2f7cafcdb386bf1a951cafff68c10c12c7db9a0924d18d02a230fbf1107a","supersedes":null},{"id":"hilton-tax:position-side","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"d6954de01c66272b0664fd0e27c04b404c71e694a5abeb3ec8485ac79996d0e9","supersedes":null},{"id":"hilton:inclusion","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"4d08d87631b650fe9b8f2c8982c7b4ca617c0489cb3fd6160e2856227018e5b2","supersedes":null},{"id":"kim-healthcare:position-side","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"168ba87cfc6edcd0784cb6ed55e7ea0f81c94eb056952d825a49709d78041a30","supersedes":null},{"id":"kim-insurance:position-side","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"7a3137c0ccda2ec7d0bcbd00edc770604289c4411ee3e0d25074fc99227f1898","supersedes":null},{"id":"kim:inclusion","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"6d25b0b753da6039a7eae61559a9b8f4a36a08e81afef4488e6f7d11c5612121","supersedes":null},{"id":"ledger.r14:source-acceptance","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"b5470313cd9b177373a5db1768083989e32656254bf913dfa0e93c3610f9578d","supersedes":null},{"id":"shaw-sports:position-side","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"120ec4d821dbb07a78fda0af6e1cd2c32dc9e101904ec48802c6c2a6843baf50","supersedes":null},{"id":"shaw:inclusion","kind":"judgment","fingerprint":"f675a71ed6b592b460f70b84f49fe0e330bbbfa7fca5c407f04f01dce7eddd2f","supersedes":null}],"merkleRoot":"3b060bb847f43e1444a48447b12eb7206779552e720348b71c49cce60bf35e16","serviceSig":{"keyId":"service:a3f979541aee7826","sig":"UxiFMDkvTHHpdz2JyeTEIJGcY48fU+6YlCt4tD+Ii1Wha0FJynAM8D+yLszJJR0G53uFcoWdEmyKCPiPdVWtDQ=="},"ownerSig":{"keyId":"SHA256:h82SrxLU1wYr+jpy4Vl9/9iQlAO+HQX1umVBdhy/Ss0","sshsig":"-----BEGIN SSH SIGNATURE-----\nU1NIU0lHAAAAAQAAAGgAAAATZWNkc2Etc2hhMi1uaXN0cDI1NgAAAAhuaXN0cDI1NgAAAE\nEEoxp1EZZ9rp5AYfMO9hQLs04GmJM0haaJgOQhAuCHlPkycB3FgiORcXWBtEUua5jLg16r\npgFNQZQ7R7CMCmON2QAAABJpZGVvbG9neS1pbnRlZ3JpdHkAAAAAAAAABnNoYTUxMgAAAG\nQAAAATZWNkc2Etc2hhMi1uaXN0cDI1NgAAAEkAAAAhAPYlLt0/5NBZzR08zBwVVfS8APzw\nG9xUJeT8ef0K5MgYAAAAIDjK9wohtDalB0tK1SnKrYKHXc5aCme4i10Q/CTo/Bu4\n-----END SSH SIGNATURE-----\n"},"receipts":[{"witness":"rfc3161","status":"ok","ref":"integrity/receipts/6/rfc3161.tsr"},{"witness":"opentimestamps","status":"pending","ref":"integrity/receipts/6/opentimestamps.ots"}]},"merkleProof":{"index":4,"path":["120ec4d821dbb07a78fda0af6e1cd2c32dc9e101904ec48802c6c2a6843baf50","6f0f36c8c6130a91218dd04c5f6eeb28fbfd5c314b9977764278bbb9f58e59f2","bcfe68f6b7707c1541b345739b0b911d105acf38f253fe04b0ef64a7fb151fb0","66432b04e03577de2e0fc407346a440af60024c308877443e9193779f565dabd","8bbdfe614d07ee1b0a4570db3cba143325c68ac2307e85fcb5e9a642711edcff","7656897dac2485da8c6c00e7afbeae9579f488d2e0b39d0809867a5fff0c0fe2","71718b513ce47408f107b5fbe446414207e9c4092724ebb99e25ce106b2db8b0"]},"versions":[{"seq":6,"publishedAt":"2026-10-03T05:31:23.125Z","fingerprint":"0ef4f0a291310f1b301262eb4ee11586debc9ce3774f1ffe0a242dbb009a499a","supersedes":null}]}}]}