Ideology

A belief question

When the state needs more tax money, where should more of it come from?

This is about who carries more of a new tax, not about whether the state should collect more.

The two sides

  • From taxpayers at every income level
  • Mostly from the people with the highest incomes or wealth

Propositions linked to this belief

Past propositions

  • Proposition 30, 2012 · Passed

    Temporary Taxes to Fund Education. Guaranteed Local Public Safety Funding. Initiative Constitutional Amendment.

    Raised personal income taxes on earnings over $250,000 for seven years and the sales tax by ¼ cent for four years to fund schools, and guaranteed public safety realignment funding.

    The official summary says Proposition 30 "Increases taxes on earnings over $250,000 for seven years and sales taxes by ¼ cent for four years, to fund schools."

    Official Voter Information Guide, November 6, 2012 General Election: Proposition 30
  • Proposition 55, 2016 · Passed

    Tax Extension to Fund Education and Healthcare. Initiative Constitutional Amendment.

    Extended through 2030 the personal income tax increases on earnings over $250,000 that were enacted in 2012, with the revenue going to K–12 schools, community colleges and, in certain years, health care.

    The official summary says Proposition 55 "Extends by twelve years the temporary personal income tax increases enacted in 2012 on earnings over $250,000, with revenues allocated to K–12 schools, California Community Colleges, and, in certain years, healthcare." A YES vote extended a rate already in place rather than adding a new tax, so this link shows no direction (owner ruling, 2026-10-03, as for Proposition 3).

    Official Voter Information Guide, November 8, 2016 General Election: Proposition 55

Before you begin

Please read this notice. By selecting “I understand and agree” you confirm that you have read it and accept it, together with the Terms of Use and the Privacy Policy.

  1. An independent experiment

    Ideology is an independent, experimental, non-commercial project, offered for information and education only. It may change, contain errors, or be withdrawn at any time without notice.

  2. No political affiliation

    The site is not affiliated with, endorsed by, funded by, or acting on behalf of any political party, candidate, campaign, list, government body, or interest group. Nothing on it is a recommendation on how to vote, nor support for or opposition to any party, candidate, or position.

  3. Prepared with artificial intelligence

    Content on the site, including summaries, translations, classifications, comparisons, verdicts, and match results, is gathered, processed, or generated in whole or in part with artificial intelligence (AI) tools. AI output may be inaccurate, incomplete, outdated, or biased. It is not verified fact and not professional, legal, or political advice. Always check the linked original sources.

  4. Your use, your responsibility

    You use the site at your own discretion and risk. It is provided “as is” and “as available”, without warranties of any kind, express or implied. To the fullest extent permitted by law, the operator is not liable for any direct, indirect, incidental, or consequential loss arising from use of, or reliance on, the site or its content. Any decision you make, including how to vote, is yours alone.

Full details: Terms · Privacy